I Loved These Boots Online, But Seeing Them IRL Had Me Ready to Commit

I know I’m in the business of online shopping, but believe me, I do just as much perusing in real life. I have been disappointed one too many times with online orders not being up to par with the quality I demand from my investments. It’s just not enough to see items virtually; I want to feel them in my hands so I can endorse them fully and honestly. You could consider us fashion editors to be quality control, and for our latest test, associate editors Nikki Chwatt and Sierra Mayhew headed to the Dr. Martens Soho and Union Square locations to check out the brand’s fall boot offerings just in time for the change of seasons. This legendary brand has been a staple in our fall wardrobes for decades, and the versatility, craftsmanship, and quality of its boots have us returning for a new pair year after year. After seeing Dr. Martens latest arrivals IRL, we’re ready to commit to the purchase. To see which boots Nikki and Sierra picked out, keep scrolling.

“As I update my wardrobe this fall, I’m looking for some versatile, high-quality pieces that I can mix and match for different looks. I’ve had my eye on a fresh pair of Dr. Martens 1460 boots for their classic, comfortable, and versatile design. The sturdy lug sole and lace-up closure make them perfect for toughening up any look, and I can’t wait to style them with everything from knit dresses and maxi skirts to tailored trousers and baggy jeans. When I went into Dr. Martens Soho store, I loved the industrial vibe—the exposed brick walls and decor, which included vintage posters and artwork, perfectly captured the brand’s DNA. I’m a huge fan of the fact that the brand has both brick-and-mortar stores and an online store, because shopping in-store allows me to interact with the products physically, try them on, and get a feel for the quality and fit.” — Nikki Chwatt, associate fashion editor

“Dr. Martens timeless collection of boots has been considered a wardrobe staple for the fall season among the fashion crowd for decades. If people can only buy one pair of shoes for the season, I always suggest a good boot and a Dr. Martens style is an absolute go-to. This style is a must for fall because it goes with anything you wear this season, whether it’s jeans and a sweater or a formal dress and trench coat, like my outfit of choice. I chose the Jadon Boot style because the height it gives me is naturally flattering and feels elevated.” — Sierra Mayhew, associate editor

Shop Additional Favorites