Another day, another Hailey Bieber makeup tutorial that has me furiously adding new staples to my cart. This time around, the beauty mogul shares a minimal, glowy beat featuring a smattering of creamy, winter-approved formulas, including a few standouts from her own brand: her newly-launched Barrier Butter, cult-favorite Pocket Blush, and… a secret cream bronzer?! I couldn’t Slack the WWW beauty team fast enough. Keep scrolling for some editor-level sleuthing.
@haileybieber currently 🫶🏼
♬ shirt by sza – audioz ⚡️
I may be grasping at straws here, but after Bieber traces her cheekbones with Westman Atelier’s Face Trace Contour Stick, she applies a tan confection to her temples and hairline—and the packaging looks suspiciously like Rhode’s best-selling Pocket Blush.
Now, I realize that many people actually use Rhode’s Pocket Blush as bronzer (a trick the TikTok crowd has dubbed “blonzing”), namely the warm Toasted Teddy shade. However, the shade Bieber wears is much, much lighter than Toasted Teddy, to the point where I wonder if it might be Freckle, the brand’s peachy-pink hue. Although, Freckle has much pinkier tones than the caramel formula Bieber uses here. Could it be the camera lighting, or could it be a new addition to the Rhode lineup? Given shoppers’ affinity for “blonzing,” it would make sense that the brand would launch a range of sun-kissed hues in the same, creamy format.
And I’m not the only one freaking out by the potential soft-launch. The comment section is swarming with questions from eagle-eyed fans begging to know when they’ll be able to get their hands on whatever Bieber is wearing. “I spot a bronzer, new blush shade, lip liner, AND a new lip tint. I’m gonna be so broke,” one user writes. (FYI: Bieber teased upcoming lip liners in a previous post, too!)
Whether she is, in fact, using a secret Rhode bronzer or just another suspiciously similar product—well, we’ll just have to wait and see. For now, feel free to browse the rest of the (available) products in Bieber’s routine, plus some other bronzers she holds dear.
Of course, Bieber’s makeup routine begins with skincare, starting with her ultra-dewy Glazing Milk.
Barrier Butter is a godsend for chapped, wintry skin—not that Bieber’s looks any less balmy.
Make Beauty
Skin Mimetic Concealer
Bieber then goes in with this creamy, buildable concealer. The fine-tipped doe-foot makes it wonderful for precise coverage.
Westman Atelier
Face Trace Contour Stick
Next, she traces her cheekbones and temples with this creamy contour stick from Westman Atelier.
After blending in the mysterious bronzer in question, she applies her beloved Pocket Blush on the apples of her cheeks. It sort of resembles a cross between Juice Box and Sleepy Girl, so I wonder if she’s also sporting a brand new rosy shade…
RMS Beauty
Redimension Hydra Powder Blush
Next, it appears she dusts this powder blush on top of her cheekbones for some extra light-reflecting power.
Hourglass
Vanish Airbrush Pressed Powder
She then lightly taps this cult-favorite Hourglass powder underneath her eyes.
Beaubble
Berry Freckled Pen
Next, she dots on some faux freckles using this rich brown, natural-looking freckle pen .
Dolce Glow
Contour Self-Tanning Sculpt + Glow
In a previous tutorial, Bieber uses this self-tanning bronzer before applying her complexion products. I’ve tested it too, and believe me, it’s a game-changer.
Tom Ford
Shade & Illuminate Contour Duo
Explore More:
